Just how far are bananas from extinction?
INIBAP, Montpellier, 21 January 2003
– The
world’s most popular fruit and a basic staple food for hundreds of
millions of people in the developing world – the banana – is under
severe threat from virulent pests and diseases. An
article in the 16 January edition of the New Scientist magazine has
warned of the risk of shoppers finding the shelves
empty when they go to buy their weekly bunch. Articles and broadcasts from
around the world have followed with alarming and
sometimes exaggerated stories of extinction.
While this helps to raise awareness of the importance of bananas in the
world and the threats faced by banana farmers, it is
important not to lose sight of the facts and to point to the positive
progress that researchers are making to address these
challenges.
The New Scientist article focussed on concerns over the spread of
a new form of Panama disease (Fusarium wilt) - known
as race 4 - which is threatening the Cavendish variety, the world’s major
export banana. The disease has spread through
plantations in Australia, South Africa and parts of Asia. It is only a
matter of time before race 4 reaches the hub of
commercial production in Latin America and the Caribbean.
The Cavendish took over as the No. 1 dessert banana in the 1960s from the
Gros Michel, a variety that had dominated world
markets until it fell prey to an earlier form of Panama disease. So fears
are justified.
Cavendish bananas are already under attack from another fungal disease,
black Sigatoka, but are protected commercially by as
many as 40 sprayings a year of fungicide. The sprayings are not only
expensive, making up a quarter of production costs,
but present a serious risk to workers and a threat to the environment.
Unlike black Sigatoka, which attacks leaves, race 4 is a soil-borne
fungus that attacks roots and cannot be controlled by
fungicides. If race 4 reaches the commercial plantations, it is likely to
wipe out Cavendish just as the earlier disease
eradicated Gros Michel. The only option is to find another variety that
resists race 4.
While the loss of the Cavendish would hurt consumers in developed
countries, diseases have an even more severe impact
on other types of banana, of which there are more than 500 varieties. Banana
exports make up just 13% of world production. The
other 87% represents bananas that never leave the country where they are
produced. In the developing world banana is the most
important food in terms of production value after rice, wheat and maize.
Most banana farmers subsist on very limited margins
and cannot afford the expensive chemicals to keep diseases in check.
Epidemic diseases that attack these bananas undermine the very roots of
food and income security for millions of people in
the developing world. New resistant varieties are needed urgently.
What makes it difficult to breed new, improved varieties is that
cultivated bananas are sterile and do not have seeds.
They are propagated as suckers, or shoots, which arise from the base of the
plant underground. There is no easy way to cross one
variety with another. It is only in the past 10 years, after more than 80
years of research, that improved varieties acceptable
for large-scale production have been made available.
Only five scientists, globally, are pres ently working to breed improved
bananas. Such a meagre research effort is decidedly
out of proportion to the scale and importance of the problem. But currently
there is alarmingly little investment in banana
research compared to the global significance of the crop. This must be
reversed if the world’s most popular fruit, an
important survival food for families in the tropics, is not to decline
further.
With the progress already made, if we can mobilise new and significant
investment, there is every reason to believe that the
banana will provide food and income security for those families for many
years to come.
Facts about the banana
· The biggest producer of
bananas is India, which produces16 million tonnes, more bananas than are
exported in world trade.
· Nearly 100 million tonnes of banana and plantain are produced globally
every year by about 120 countries in subtropical and
tropical zones.
· The export trade concerns around only about 12.5 million tonnes of
banana.
· Roughly equal amounts are produced from each of the regions of Asia,
Latin America with the Caribbean, and Africa.
· There are more than 500 varieties of banana in the world. The Cavendish
banana is the one that is exported and found on
supermarket shelves. It represents just one var iety.
· The highest rate of consumption is in East Africa. Ugandans produce
10.5 million tonnes, around 450 kg per year per
person. The word for bananas "matooke" also means "food".
· 99.5% of banana-eaters in the world are eating varieties of banana that
ha ve been selected by farmers and haven’t changed in
centuries.
· The fruit is one of the most easily digested foods available, and is
particularly useful in feeding infants, the frail or
ailing (and sportsmen in need of quick energy), providing a good source of
potassium, calcium, phosphorus, vitamins A, B6 and C.
· Black Sigatoka causes yield declines of up to 50%. Commercial
plantations follow a very intensive regime of
fungicide spraying – up to 40 times a season -- to combat black Sigatoka.
· Almost all cultivated bananas are difficult to breed because they are
seedless and sterile. They also take up to 18 months
to fruit, which prolongs breeding efforts compared to annual crops.
· Improved varieties produced by classical breeding have started to
become available in the past 10 years. They have not
yet been planted on a large scale.
· Cuba is the first country to use improved varieties of banana on a
significant scale. They have planted more than 11,000
ha. As a result, farmers have experienced yield increases and made annual
savings of US$3 million on spraying.
· Biotechnology can speed up research dramatically. Classical plant
breeding can use biotechnologies to see which
varieties are worth pursuing. And genetic modification is one biotechnology
that could be used to breed improved varieties of
banana. In cases where varieties are totally sterile, it is the only
available solution. Genetically manipulated bananas
would be environmentally safe because the banana is sterile
and modified genes would not be able to escape from the transformed
crop.
· Plantain is one kind of cooking banana. It represents a group of
bananas that are popular in parts of South Asia, West
Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean.
The International Network for the Improvement of Banana and Plantain (INIBAP)
is a programme of the International Plant Genetic
Resources Institute (IPGRI), one of the Future Harvest centres of the
Consultative Group on International Agricultural
Research (CGIAR).
INIBAP coordinates research and carries out hundreds of projects
worldwide on the smallholder banana crop. It manages
the largest collection of banana germplasm in a genebank held at the
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (KULeuven) in Belgium.
Future Harvest
(www.futureharvest.org)
is a global nonprofit organization that builds awareness and support
for food and environmental research for a world with less poverty, a
healthier human family, well-nourished children, and
a better environment. Future Harvest supports the 16 food and environmental
research centers that are primarily funded through
the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research
(www.cgiar.org).
The Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR)
(www.cgiar.org)
is a strategic alliance of 58 members and 16 Future Harvest Centers that mobilizes
cutting-edge science to promote sustainable
development by reducing hunger and poverty, improving human nutrition and
health, and protecting the environment.
|